What Kind of Writer Are You?

Posted by: Janice Hardy  :  Category: Write a Novel

After reading that title, you likely had some kind of answer. Most would probably reply with the genre they write. A fantasy writer, a fiction writer, an outliner, a pantser. When folks ask me that question, I say “I write fantasy for teens.”

But deep down, it’s more than that.
Earlier this year at the 2010 RWA Conference, I had an eye-opening experience. I sat in on a session about theme with English professor and literary critic Sarah Frantz, and romance author Suzanne Brockmann.

They utterly blew me away with their thoughts on theme (that’s a whole different post), but one thing that really resonated with me was when the author said she had a career theme.

A career theme? Whoa. What was that?

In this case, a career theme wasn’t a “What am I going to do when I grow up” question. It was more, “What am I going to do with my characters as they grow up,” question. In other words, what is the central theme that I weave through all my writing, regardless of it’s genre?

I’d never thought about it, but a career theme made sense, especially since I’d had a meeting with my agent that very morning about what project I should work on next. She’d liked one of my ideas because it had a moral gray area, same as my Healing Wars trilogy. Writing in a gray area had worked for me already, and it was the kind of story I enjoyed telling. Folks stuck in the middle where there was no clear right or wrong. Tales that made you think about what you would do in that situation.

This was a theme I could work with no matter what story I was writing. It was universal (as many good themes are) and offered depths I could plumb for conflicts. It also gave me something to think about when I was deciding if a story idea was going to work on not. I’m sure I’m not alone when it comes to staring at a list of ideas and wondering which one I should write next.

During that “next book meeting” with my agent, several of my ideas had sounded interesting, but she said there wasn’t enough inherent conflict in them to carry a whole novel. And she was right. The one that did have enough conflict had that moral gray area, because the theme had conflict on its own, and that translated to the specific story idea.

So, my career theme became: “Moral Gray Areas.” And this is how I benefited from picking it:

  • The theme actually helped me see and develop conflicts in my ideas.
  • The theme was also something that could help my writing career, by strengthening my identity as a writer.
  • If I ever want to try a new genre or age market, my theme can still tie all my work together.

That could make it more appealing for a reader of one genre to try me in another – a common problem when you switch genres. Readers don’t always follow you if you write a genre they don’t read. But if they like some universal idea and all your stories have that, it makes it easier to retain readers.

Back when I wrote my first book, The Shifter, I had no clear theme in mind. But since I was already playing with the moral gray area, it just developed as the story unfolded. “How many bad things can you do and still be a good person?” I guess you can even say, does the end justify the means? Another theme that developed was being trapped. Physically, economically, emotionally – almost everyone in the book is trapped in some way. So Book One became a story about a girl trapped in a situation where she’s forced to do bad things for good reasons.

When the second book (Blue Fire) came along, I knew my themes, though I hadn’t yet discovered my career theme idea. But in fiction at least, I was continuing my “bad things/good person” theme. This time, however, the secondary theme was about escape. My protag struggled with trying to escape A) the guilt over what she’d done in book one, B) the consequences of those actions, and C) doing it again. You can even see those themes in the book’s cover blurb:

Part fugitive, part hero, fifteen-year-old Nya is barely staying ahead of the Duke of Baseer’s trackers. Wanted for a crime she didn’t mean to commit, she risks capture to protect every Taker she can find, determined to prevent the Duke from using them in his fiendish experiments. But resolve isn’t enough to protect any of them, and Nya soon realizes that the only way to keep them all out of the Duke’s clutches is to flee Geveg. Unfortunately, the Duke’s best tracker has other ideas.

Nya finds herself trapped in the last place she ever wanted to be, forced to trust the last people she ever thought she could. More is at stake than just the people of Geveg, and the closer she gets to uncovering the Duke’s plan, the more she discovers how critical she is to his victory. To save Geveg, she just might have to save Baseer—if she doesn’t destroy it first.

The “Moral Gray Areas” theme is expressed in the following ways:

Guilt: Nya didn’t mean to commit a crime. She risks capture to protect others caught up in that. She has to get them out to keep them safe.
Nya is tracked and wanted by authorities, trapped and taken someplace else and trying to uncover plans.
Doing it Again:
Ny earns that resolve isn’t enough. To save one thing she loves, she might have to destroy the other. This is her critical role.

Some of these points won’t be clear if you didn’t read Book One: The Shifter, but they refer to things that all center on the theme “Moral Grey Areas.”

This theme also continues in book three (out next October), along with the added theme of taking responsibility and taking a stand. Nya still struggles with everything she’s been through, but as she grows over the course of the series, that theme has also grown. She might still be trapped and trying to escape, but this time, she’s doing it on her terms, and figuring out where that line she can’t cross really is.

And for me? No longer am I someone who just writes fantasy for teens. Now, I’m someone who writes fantasy that explores the moral gray area between right and wrong.

If you’re still developing your skills and figuring out what kind of writer you want to be overall, theme might not be something you have to worry about yet. But thinking about the types of stories you like thematically, could gain you valuable insights into your own style. And if you’re embarking on a publishing career, determining what niche you might fill could save you headaches later on.

Janice Hardy Bio
A long-time fantasy reader, Janice Hardy always wondered about the darker side of healing. For her fantasy trilogy THE HEALING WARS, she tapped into her own dark side to create a world where healing was dangerous, and those with the best intentions often made the worst choices. Her books include THE SHIFTER, and BLUE FIRE from Balzer+Bray/Harper Collins.  She lives in Georgia with her husband, three cats and one very nervous freshwater eel.

Visit Janice:
Website: www.janicehardy.com

Blog: “The Other Side of the Story”
Link to: Blue Fire Online Retailer

To keep from missing any great writing articles, please subscribe.

30 Responses to “What Kind of Writer Are You?”

  1. Rachna Chhabria Says:

    Thanks for this awesome post. I had never thought along those lines. A Career Theme is a wonderful concept.

    Actually if we look deep within our stories, there is an underlying common theme in all our stories; this common theme arises out of our inner beliefs. It also connects all our stories regardless of the genre, and it does retain readers when we get experimental as they can identify with the basic theme (career theme) which they have come to identify with each writer.

    Thanks for sharing!:)

  2. Janice Hardy Says:

    Twitter: Janice_Hardy
    Most welcome. It was such a light bulb moment for me, and made the whole conference worth it (it was good anyway). And you’re right, we do bring ourselves to our work, so it makes perfect sense that we have common themes even if we didn’t do it on purpose.

  3. Birgitte Says:

    Twitter: necessarywriter
    Thank you so much for this post, Janice. I too love the idea of a “career theme.” In looking back on my own work I see a theme developing that I could call a career theme if it’s one that is sellable. Seems all my characters are tweaked and have crazy mothers. LOL Is that a theme???

    Thank you again for posting. I love your books!!!!


  4. Mazarine Memon Says:

    What an insightful post Janice. The most wonderful advice was to take notice of the kind of books one reads and that in itself gives you an idea of the ones that appeal to you thematically.
    I have that list of ideas and now have to way to determine what might work as a work! :)

  5. Tweets that mention » Blog Archive » What Kind of Writer Are You? -- Topsy.com Says:

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Birgitte Necessary, Birgitte Necessary. Birgitte Necessary said: What Kind of Writer Are You? http://is.gd/gjt1j […]

  6. Vonna Says:

    Aren’t conferences great? I always come away with some wonderful new insight. Thanks for sharing this one. A career theme really is what draws me to certain writers.

  7. Melissa Says:

    Twitter: CrytzerFry
    Thanks for the fresh take on defining our writing, Janice. I agree that we gravitate toward READING certain genres/themes in fiction. And, as they say, ‘You write what you read.’ My ‘working’ career theme seems to be “woman against the odds.” Must think about this a bit more!
    .-= Melissa´s last blog ..Lifesaving Intervention =-.

  8. Janice Hardy Says:

    Twitter: Janice_Hardy
    Ms B, I think tweaked and crazy mothers could be a theme. Or even broaden it to crazy family members.

    I always learn something new at a conference. After that one, I’ve been thinking about theme so much more. I’m very curious (and eager) to see what I do with it for my next novel. I wonder how I’ll approach it differently? I think my outline template is going to change!

    Melissa, that’s so true. And when I started looking at the books I loved, but in genres I didn’t write, I saw the themes that I enjoyed.

  9. Lia Keyes Says:

    Twitter: liakeyes
    Love this post! There’s nearly always a theme running through a writer’s canon of work, but often the writer himself is unaware of it. How much more powerful the work might be if writers were conscious of the choices they were making, and why.

  10. Claudine Says:

    This is great! I actually think this is going to help me define my mc’s goal. I kind of knew the what, but not the why.
    Love the idea that my theme can cross genres. Even age groups. I’m going to look at a MG I’m working on now also to see if the theme is present there, as well as in my sci/fi.

  11. Birgitte Says:

    Twitter: necessarywriter
    Janice, in what way do you think your outline template will change?

  12. Janice Hardy Says:

    Twitter: Janice_Hardy
    Birgitte, I think I’ll try looking at a thematic arc as well as plot and character arcs. It might not work, but it might be a nice support structure to tie the story together. Give me another line of thought to explore when I’m deciding on plot twists and potential problems.

  13. Free Traffic Says:

    Please do not stop your great post. I will continue to read all of your post.

  14. Lashawnda Says:

    The current mobile operators mobile games platform also can not satisfy the majority of mobile phone
    users to easily understand and facilitate the needs of mobile game downloads, the market is also a lack of more platform choices, other than the platform operators often because
    of policy and management such constraints have not been healthy development.

    Symbian mobile games are increasingly becoming essential source of entertainment and being
    most utmost capabilities in the whole world. keeps on changing the recent boom in mobile gaming sector seems to be the best alternative in this chaotic and stressful life.

  15. Cheat Dragon City Food And Gold Says:

    is updated frequently with free advice about Google
    Ad – Words strategy, tactics, tips tricks and techniques for success in Ad – Words advertising.
    This will allow you to answer only those calls that come in on your
    forwarded toll free number and route other calls to different locations.

    And then on March 20, the world’s largest paid private blog network – BMR –
    announced that its vast network had been almost
    entirely de-indexed by Google, causing chaos in the internet
    marketing industries.

  16. Manuela Says:

    It will also increase the ranking of your website on search engines and will drive more traffic to your website.
    Based on their experience, they could know how much is required
    before going into details. What Googlebot is looking to see in the Free Local
    Google Advertising Listings is quite another.

  17. Darnell Says:

    I see a lot of interesting content on your website. You have to spend a lot of time writing, i know how to save you a lot of time, there
    is a tool that creates readable, SEO friendly posts in couple of minutes, just
    search in google – k2 unlimited content

  18. Google Says:

    is updated frequently with free advice about Google Ad – Words strategy, tactics, tips
    tricks and techniques for success in Ad – Words advertising.
    This will allow you to answer only those calls that come in on your
    forwarded toll free number and route other calls to different
    locations. Besides placing advertisers ads on your Blog, you can also make money Blogging
    by placing Google Adsense into your Blog.

  19. Fredericka Says:

    I read a lot of interesting content here. Probably you spend a lot of time writing, i know
    how to save you a lot of time, there is an online tool that creates unique,
    google friendly articles in minutes, just search in google – laranitas
    free content source

  20. Sheryl Says:

    Eating healthy can be a very daunting task for many people.
    All these factors must go hand-in-hand in order to ensure a more balanced and fit
    result that can only be achieved through the success of being able to maintain the harmony between these factors.
    We must know that what we eat has a dramatic effect on our health.

  21. save money Says:

    Twitter: save money
    @Jenna I have a big problem with white women to be the group benefit the most from AA. That is far from the original intent of AA. I see you first as white and second as woman. I agree with almost everything you said about women, but it does not seem to me you care about anyone else besides that. Your values to me are as white as they can be. Either you ignored your own blind spots or you came to the wrong blog.
    save money http://peek.snurl.com/waystosavemoneyathomevision845450

  22. nachrichten flüchtlinge ungarn Says:

    Nachrichten sind vor ihrer Verbreitung mit der nach den Umständen gebotenen Sorgfalt auf Wahrheit und Herkunft zu prüfen, Kommentare sind von der Berichterstattung
    deutlich zu trennen und unter Nennung des Verfassers als solche zu kennzeichnen (§ 10 Abs.
    nachrichten flüchtlinge ungarn´s last blog post ..nachrichten flüchtlinge ungarn

  23. Medizin Wissen Online Says:

    Ab diesem Zeitpunkt sollte man damit beginnen, das Baby in sein eigenes Kinderbett zum Schlafen zu legen.
    Medizin Wissen Online´s last blog post ..Medizin Wissen Online

  24. Gesundheit und Ernaehrung Says:

    Das Wissen über die richtige Ernährung im
    Vergleich dazu jedoch relativ gering.
    Gesundheit und Ernaehrung´s last blog post ..Gesundheit und Ernaehrung

  25. Rowena Says:

    Wer mehr macht, senkt zwar sein Sterberisiko weiter, aber
    nur noch um zehn bis 15 Prozent.
    Rowena´s last blog post ..Rowena

  26. riehner.wordpress.com Says:

    Gut, sauber und fair müssen Slow-Food-Produkte laut Definition von Gründer Carlo Petrini sein.
    riehner.wordpress.com´s last blog post ..riehner.wordpress.com

  27. ezangl78.tumblr.com Says:

    Die Ultraschalluntersuchung wird häufig in der Schwangerschaft angewendet, weil diese
    unbedenklich für Mutter und Baby ist.
    ezangl78.tumblr.com´s last blog post ..ezangl78.tumblr.com

  28. riehner.blogspot.co.at Says:

    Fettstoffwechsel aktivieren kann man gezielt am besten mit einer auf das persönliche Leistungsvermögen angepasste,
    moderate Bewegung.
    riehner.blogspot.co.at´s last blog post ..riehner.blogspot.co.at

  29. Was ist Gesundheit Who Says:

    Sie ist leidenschaftliche Sudoku-Löserin und hat diverse Hefte und Blöcke herum fliegen, die nach
    und nach immer mehr kaputt gehen.
    Was ist Gesundheit Who´s last blog post ..Was ist Gesundheit Who

  30. 98Nestor Says:

    I must say you have high quality content here. Your page should go viral.
    You need initial boost only. How to get it? Search for:
    Etorofer’s strategies
    98Nestor´s last blog post ..98Nestor

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

14a67c6705" />